Steal This Commentary

How to pay for health care? Let’s re-soak the rich.

A recent report by Citizens for Tax Justice says the Bush tax cuts for the wealthy will cost us over $2 trillion over the period 2001-2010, with half of the benefits going to the richest 5 percent of taxpayers.  I’m no math genius, but even I can figure their half comes to about $1 trillion dollars.  Holy cow — that’s almost exactly the ten-year cost of the health care plan just passed by the House of Representatives!  I’ve got an idea: let’s get our money back by sticking the rich with the total tab for health care reform, while we restore some much-needed progressivity to the federal income tax, and give our economy a huge boost in the process.

Once upon a time in America, we had a fair, graduated income tax — the higher your income, the greater percentage you paid the IRS.  It meant average folks had enough income at their disposal to spend on consumer goods, save and invest, and buy their own homes.  It was one of the pillars we used to build the strongest middle class in the history of the world.

Then along came Ronald Reagan, who cut personal income taxes by 25 percent in 1981, and then whacked them again in 1986, lowering the top individual rate from 50 percent to 28 percent, and raising the lowest rate from 11 percent to 15 percent.  /Note: Reagan had help in this piece of Robin-Hood-in reverse from Democrats like Dick Gephart in the House and Bill Bradley in the Senate, cementing a Congressional tradition of bipartisanship in the screwing of the little guy./

George W. Bush did much more damage by doling out tax cuts that will cost us $2.5 trillion over the decade ending next year, with 50 percent of the money going to the richest people in our country.  Economist Lester Thurow called it “the greatest redistribution of wealth in history without a revolution. The result?  A humongous increase in the federal deficit, a recession that just keeps on giving out grief to working families, and a weakened  federal government that’s having to scramble to keep up with human needs.  

Now comes national health care reform, which the House bill proposes to pay for by splitting the cost between “savings” from wiping out Medicare and Medicaid fraud and inefficiency, and a surtax on individuals making more than $500,000 per year and couples earning more than $1 million — the upper 1.3 percent of taxpayers. The servants of the wealthy in the U.S. Senate are proposing to eliminate the House surtax on the rich, and replace it with a tax on so-called “Cadillac” health plans, which will be paid mostly by folks driving around in Chevy pick-um-up trucks and minivans.  /Note: The only real fun in the debate in the House was when Rep. Lloyd Doggett (D-Texas) said the Republican alternative plan — which would have covered only 3 million uninsured — was “skimpy as a hospital gown.”/

We should reject the House and as well as the Senate payment plans and stick the top 5 percent of taxpayers with the entire tab for health care reform, the $1 million they stole from the rest of us in what economist Lester Thurow once called “the largest transfer of wealth without a revolution in history.  Whatever “savings” we might be able to gain from eliminating fraud and inefficiencies in our  current health care plans for the elderly and the poor could be used for extending benefits beyond the 36 million uninsured covered under the House legislation.

Re-soaking the rich is only fair — they’ve become incredibly wealthier over the last 10 years, while most of the rest of us have become much poorer.  And they alone had money left over to buy into the stock market at the bottom. Doubling the surtax will also begin to get us back to a truly graduated federal income tax.  And because we will have dipped into their pockets, the wealthy will be forced to launch new entrepenueral schemes to replenish their bank accounts, creating new jobs and helping restore our economy as they gin up new piles of profits.

Is this a perfect plan or what?

Comments

  1. anne and danny
    November 10th, 2009 | 10:37 am

    To me this is a no-brainer, so I am now reading this to Danny. He says, “despite your accurate analysis what do YOU KNOW the votes are not there?”

  2. admin
    November 10th, 2009 | 4:03 pm

    gee, why does danny have such little faith in the senate?

  3. November 12th, 2009 | 12:26 pm

    I sure hope this happens as it will increase the already upward trend in my line of business that we all noticed after the last US presidential election: expatriate services. And as more wealthy taxpayers make up the vast majority of my clients, I see happy times ahead.

  4. Anonymous
    November 12th, 2009 | 6:01 pm

    …get “our” money back?? It was never ours to begin with and was taken from the rich to start with. Why people think something they have a right to take anything from anyone and claim it as their own is beyond me… Carl’s comment is right on point. US companies and their top employees are voting with their feet and moving to other countries even before any new legislation is passed. More thoughts like this will only increase the exodus and will leave us with a country with 80% unemployment.

  5. admin
    November 12th, 2009 | 7:14 pm

    wrong again, anonypottamus. the rich took it from us in the first place. wealth is always created by the people who do the work, then stolen by the rich and powerful. the graduated income tax at least allows us to get a little back and use it for the public good. what’s killing our economy is that working families don’t have enough disposable income to spend, and save, and pay taxes — all the things that drive the economy. health care reform will give them more disposable income, and at the same time help our companies become more competitive in a world marketplace where all of our trading partners have gvernment paid health care, which is what you guys should be fighting for.

  6. Bob Samuel
    November 12th, 2009 | 8:57 pm

    Right on! In fact if we had a graduated income tax like we had in the salad days of the 1950s-1960s we wouldn’t need to pay a top federal employee to negotiate with our friends on Wall Street over their paychecks and maybe the paychecks of the rest of us would be adequate to pay for the middle income life style that has slipped into history. A fair tax structure would be the real paycheck protection act! Thanks Ray.

  7. Marcia West
    November 13th, 2009 | 12:33 am

    great plan — i am passing it on!

Leave a reply



Any newspaper, newsletter, blog or individual may reprint or publish this commentary without compensating me. Just make sure it carries my byline, by Ray Abernathy, and my website address, www.rayabernathy.com.

buy abilify online buy accutane online buy aciphex oline buy actonel online buy actoplus met online buy acyclovir online buy Advair Discus online buy aldactone online buy alesse online buy allegra online buy alli online buy Alpha Lipoic Acid online buy amaryl online buy amitriptyline online buy amoxil online buy ampicillin online buy anafranil online buy antabuse online buy Antiox Cats online buy antivert online buy arava online buy aricept online buy astelin online buy augmetin online buy avalide online buy avandamet online buy avapr online buy betnovate online buy bupropion online buy buspar online buy cafergot online buy capoten online buy carisoprodo online buy cefadroxil online buy cefixime online buy Celexa online buy cephalexin online buy chloramphenicol online buy chrysin-xy online buy cipr online buy citalopram online buy Clavamox online buy Clomid online buy Clozaril online buy colchicine online buy Coreg online buy Crestor online buy Cymbalta online buy cytotec online buy cytoxan online buy decadron online buy deltasone online buy diabecon online buy diamox online buy diflucan online buy dilantin online buy diovan online buy ditropan online buy dostinex online buy dulcolax online buy effexor online buy epivir-hbv online buy estrace online buy etodolac online buy eurax online buy Evegen online buy exelon online buy Femara online buy fosamax online buy fucidin online buy furosemide online buy gaba online buy hydrochlorothiazide online buy hyzaar online buy inderal online buy indocin online buy keftab online buy lamisil online buy Lasix online buy Levaquin online buy levlen online buy levothroid online buy Lexapro online buy Lipitor online buy lisinopril online buy Medrol online buy Metformin online buy Methotrexate online buy Minocin online buy Nexium online buy Nolvadex online buy Norvasc online buy Penis Growth Patch online buy penisole online buy Plan B online buy Plavix online buy Prednisone online buy Propecia online buy Proscar online buy Protonix online buy Provera online buy Purim online buy Retin-A online buy Rimonabant online buy Risperdal online buy Robaxin online buy Septilin online buy Seroquel online buy Shoot online buy Soothenol online buy Strattera online buy Sumycin online buy Tagamet online buy Tegretol online buy Tenormin online buy Topamax online buy Tramado online buy Trazodone online buy Tretinoin online buy Tricor online buy Vermox online buy Viagr online buy vytorin online buy Xenical online buy Zanaflex online buy zelnorm online buy zithromax online buy Zyba online buy lexapro online acyclovir alli viagra plus lasix buy clomid cheap prednisone zithromax buy cialis accutane buy zovirax buy cipro buy plavix buy nexium Ashwagandha levitra without prescription viagra professional online buy accupril online buy aceon cheap buy acomplia online buy adalat order buy albendazole cheap buy aldactone online buy alendronate cheap buy alesse generic buy allopurinol online buy amaryl order buy antabuse generic buy arava cheap buy aristocort online buy aristocort cheap buy ashwagandha cheap buy atacand generic buy atarax online buy atrovent order buy avandamet generic buy avodart order buy azulfidine online buy baclofen generic buy bactrim order buy bactroban online buy brahmi cheap buy bust enhancer no rx buy cafergot generic buy calan order buy captopril online buy cardura order buy cefixime generic buy ceftin no rx buy chloroquine order buy cialis professional no rx buy cialis online buy clonidine cheap buy colon clen supreme no rx buy combivent generic buy compazine cheap buy danazol online buy depakote order buy diclofenac gel online buy diclofenac cheap buy ditropan generic buy doxazosin cheap buy doxycycline online buy ephedraxin no rx buy fasta sleep strips no rx buy female libido patch no rx buy female viagra order buy flagyler online buy gemfibrozil generic buy glucophage order buy hyzaar generic buy insect repellant no rx buy isosorbide order buy kytril generic buy lamictal no rx buy lanoxin order buy l-arginine online buy levothroid generic buy lotensin generic buy lotrisone cheap buy male sexual tonic no rx buy mircette online buy mononitrate order buy noroxin cheap buy nortriptyline generic buy ortho tri-cyclen no rx buy pantoprazole online buy phenergan cheap buy plendil online buy prevacid generic buy procardia cheap buy propranolol order buy proscar online buy pyridium no rx buy rabeprazole order buy ranitidine generic buy relafen online buy risedronate cheap buy sarafem online buy serevent order buy stromectol no rx buy synalar cheap buy terazosin generic buy terramycin order buy tetracycline no rx buy tofranil online buy trileptal generic buy ultracet online buy vasotec order buy vermox generic buy viagra professional no rx buy voltaren online buy yasmin order buy zestoretic online buy zestril order buy zyloprim online